Stone Hill at Muttontown
75 Stone Hill Dr, Muttontown, NY 11791
Stone Hill at Muttontown Community
75 Stone Hill Dr, Muttontown, NY 11791 | Nassau, NY county
Stone Hill at Muttontown is an extraordinary gated estate community set amid 148 acres of rolling hills, mature trees, and meticulously maintained grounds in the prestigious Village of Muttontown on Long Island’s North Shore. Influenced by classic European design and developed on the former estate of Wall Street financier B.K. Stevens, this exclusive enclave offers a rare blend of historic significance, natural beauty, and refined modern living. With just 80 estate home-sites, Stone Hill provides a sense of intimacy and privacy that is increasingly difficult to find.
Homesites range from one acre to more than two and a half acres, allowing residences to feel truly estate-like in scale and presence. The landscape unfolds with sweeping vistas, preserved green space, and gently winding roads that enhance the community’s serene, country-like atmosphere. Despite its tranquil setting, Stone Hill is ideally located 35 minutes from Manhattan, minutes from the Long Island Rail Road, and close to premier shopping, dining, and cultural destinations.
Each home within Stone Hill is individually customized, ensuring no two estates are alike. This thoughtful approach to design results in a community defined by architectural distinction and personal expression. The setting encourages a lifestyle that values space, elegance, and quiet sophistication, while the surrounding natural beauty creates a feeling of retreat that endures year-round.
1.25 acres
Average Lot Size
3
Active Listings
68
Total Housing Units
5,894
Average Square Footage
Resident Amenities
sports_basketball
Basketball Court
family_group
Clubhouse
fitness_center
Fitness Center
award_star
Gated Community
award_star
Grounds & Common Area Maintenance
pool
Pool
sports_tennis
Tennis Court
Schedule a visit
Tour for free, no strings attached.
Learn the Stone Hill at Muttontown Story
Schedule a visit
Tour for free, no strings attached.
Resident Amenities
expand_lessActive Listings & Homes For Sale and For Rent
| Photo | Lot | Price | Beds | Baths | Square Feet | HOA Fees | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loading listings data... | |||||||
Interactive Map
Stone Hill at Muttontown Community (and nearby)Stone Hill at Muttontown Residences
Data loading...
Available Home Models
Framingham
Priced from $5,750,000
The Framingham is a six-bedroom, 6,876-square-foot single-family residence with 5.5 bathrooms and 15 rooms. Its grand foyer features a bridal staircase, while the floor plan includes a music room, office or library, sunroom, and breakfast room. An elevator serves all floors, and the home has a full basement with optional finishing. Stone Hill at Muttontown is a 24-hour gated community, with tennis among its amenities. The Framingham’s six bedrooms and expansive layout offer a larger home than the Silver Shadow model.
- Single Family Residence
- Build Type
- 6
- Beds
- 5.5
- Baths
- 6,876
- Sqft
- —
- Garages
- —
- Stories
Silver Shadow
The Silver Shadow is a four-bedroom, 4,860-square-foot single-family residence with 5.5 bathrooms and 11 rooms. This fully upgraded model features two primary suites, an exquisite kitchen, and marble finishes. Its flat, landscaped yard includes an in-ground pool and cabana. Stone Hill at Muttontown also offers a clubhouse, community pool, tennis, fitness facilities, and 24-hour gated security. Compared with the Framingham, the Silver Shadow has fewer bedrooms and less living area, while offering two primary suites and a private pool-and-cabana setting.
- Single Family Residence
- Build Type
- 4
- Beds
- 5.5
- Baths
- 4,860
- Sqft
- —
- Garages
- —
- Stories
Available Home Models
Framingham
Priced from $5,750,000
- Single Family Residence
- Build Type
- 6
- Beds
- 5.5
- Baths
- 6,876
- Sqft
- —
- Garages
- —
- Stories
The Framingham is a six-bedroom, 6,876-square-foot single-family residence with 5.5 bathrooms and 15 rooms. Its grand foyer features a bridal staircase, while the floor plan includes a music room, office or library, sunroom, and breakfast room. An elevator serves all floors, and the home has a full basement with optional finishing. Stone Hill at Muttontown is a 24-hour gated community, with tennis among its amenities. The Framingham’s six bedrooms and expansive layout offer a larger home than the Silver Shadow model.
Silver Shadow
- Single Family Residence
- Build Type
- 4
- Beds
- 5.5
- Baths
- 4,860
- Sqft
- —
- Garages
- —
- Stories
The Silver Shadow is a four-bedroom, 4,860-square-foot single-family residence with 5.5 bathrooms and 11 rooms. This fully upgraded model features two primary suites, an exquisite kitchen, and marble finishes. Its flat, landscaped yard includes an in-ground pool and cabana. Stone Hill at Muttontown also offers a clubhouse, community pool, tennis, fitness facilities, and 24-hour gated security. Compared with the Framingham, the Silver Shadow has fewer bedrooms and less living area, while offering two primary suites and a private pool-and-cabana setting.
Recent Activity at The Stone Hill at Muttontown Community
| Date | Lot | Status | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Loading activity data... | |||
Community Facts
- Community Name: Stone Hill at Muttontown
- Neighborhood: Muttontown
- Year Established: 2005
- Total Homes: 68 residences
- Property Type: Houses, Townhomes
- County: Nassau, NY county
- Available Sales Listings: 3
- Available Rental Listings: 0
- Lifestyle & HOA: Life at Stone Hill at Muttontown is centered on privacy, security, and effortless luxury. The community is protected by a double-gated, 24-hour manned entrance with advanced surveillance, providing residents with peace of mind and a heightened sense of exclusivity. Beyond the gates, residents enjoy access to a private clubhouse that serves as both a social and wellness hub. Amenities include a heated indoor swimming pool, private tennis facilities, a state-of-the-art fitness center, locker rooms, and comfortable gathering spaces designed for both casual and formal occasions. The homeowners association plays an integral role in maintaining the community’s pristine appearance and ease of living. Services include professional landscaping for individual estates, upkeep of the extensive common areas, and driveway snow removal. More than 29 acres of common land, much of it deed-restricted are preserved in their natural state, ensuring the beauty and openness of the community remain protected for generations. Additional deed-restricted open space within individual lots further enhances the sense of privacy and harmony with nature. Stone Hill also features a unique equestrian trail encircling the community, adding to its distinctive character and reinforcing its connection to the surrounding landscape. With its combination of estate-level privacy, luxury amenities, and comprehensive HOA services, Stone Hill at Muttontown offers a lifestyle that is both refined and remarkably easy. Ideal for those seeking elegance without compromise in one of Long Island’s most prestigious settings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Learn more about the Stone Hill at Muttontown community and available homes for sale and rent here in Muttontown.
When was Stone Hill at Muttontown built?
Stone Hill at Muttontown was built in 2005.
Where is Stone Hill at Muttontown located?
Stone Hill at Muttontown is located at 75 Stone Hill Dr in Muttontown in NY.
What amenities does the Stone Hill at Muttontown community provide?
Stone Hill at Muttontown provides the following resident amenities: Basketball Court, Clubhouse, Fitness Center, Gated Community, Grounds & Common Area Maintenance, Pool, Tennis Court.
What county is Stone Hill at Muttontown located in?
Stone Hill at Muttontown is located in Nassau, NY county.
How many homes are currently available in Stone Hill at Muttontown for sale or for rent?
Out of 68 homes in Stone Hill at Muttontown, there are currently 3 sales listings and 0 rental listings available.
What is the average square footage in the Stone Hill at Muttontown community?
The average square footage of homes in Stone Hill at Muttontown is 5894 sq.ft.
How big is the Stone Hill at Muttontown community?
The Stone Hill at Muttontown community is made up of 68 homes with an average lot size of 54342 sq.ft.
Schedule a Visit
Ask a Question
Join Waitlist
Save this Home to Your Profile
Save this home, get price drop and status alerts, and view your favorites anytime.
OR
By continuing, you agree to receive email updates from Casamere related to your saved items. You can manage your preferences or unsubscribe at any time. See our Terms & Privacy Policy
To continue, click the link sent to
Not seeing the email in your inbox?